For several days now, I?ve been in a running argument with an individual who goes by the name of ?On Lawn? over in the comments sections of the blog ran by anti-gay equality group National Organization for Marriage. In several comments here, here, and here, this person seems to imply that procreation, or at least the potential for procreation, is a requirement of marriage. I?ve tried several times to get this person to explain this concept but they keep brushing off the question calling it absurd. When I tried to point out that there is no link between marriage and procreation they came back with this.
Well, there shows the damage they want to do to the institution. If marriage can?t look equally at the interests of all involved in the practice of human mating, then you tell me what can.
Prehistoric humans didn?t marry before they mated, they just found a bush did it. When you look at the whole of human history, marriage is a relatively new creation, only being a few thousand years old. Our very existence proves that marriage is not a requirement or an essential element of the human mating process.
Archive for December 8, 2008
Oral Arguments
Tomorrow at 10 am the Iowa State Supreme court begins hearing Oral Arguments on the status of same-sex marriage in Iowa. While Lamda Legal will argue that the couples constitutional rights have been violated Polk county will argue that the issue of same-sex marriage should be up to lawmakers and not the courts.
I counter Polk counties arguments with this.
1. There are currently no laws on the Iowa books prohibiting same-sex marriage. Same-sex couples are currently being denied marriage rights by county auditors that refuse to grant them licenses. The court then has every right to step in and make sure that county auditors are following the laws and both the state and federal constitutions as they are written.
2. Lawmakers have all ready attempted and failed at passing a constitutional amendment baring same-sex couples. It is in my opinion that they have then settled the issue and same-sex couples should be allowed to marry.
